Blue Rhino Gas

Blue Rhino Propane Exchange

Don't be caught in the middle of a BBQ without propane! Keep a spare full tank handy. You'll be glad you did!

We sell Radio Flyer

We Sell Radio Flyer!

Agnew & Taylor Hardware is one of Long Island's most stocked Radio Flyer dealers with a large on hand stock of wagons, bikes and ride-ons.

We sell Benjamin Moore Paints

Paint Something Today

We carry a huge selection of Benjamin Moore paints and products. Stop in to talk to a knowledgeable member of our staff today.

Glass and Plexiglass Cut to Size

If you are looking for glass or plexiglass in New York state, then you have come to the right place!

Lake Ronkonkoma's LocalTrue ValueHardware Store
For Over 100 Years!

The local hardware store for Suffolk and Nassau County.
A short distance from Manhattan, Bronx, Queens, Brooklyn and Staten Island. Delivery options available.

About Agnew & Taylor Hardware

July Bargains of the Month next prev

  •  $19.99

    Westpointe Oscillating Tower Fan

    3 Speeds, 27-Inch

  •  $9.97

    Master Electrician Extension Cord

    16/2 Orange, Lighted Ends, 50-Ft.

  •  $24.99

    Four Seasons Courtyard Oversized Padded Arm Chair


  • Solar-Power Fluttering Butterfly or Hummingbird at True Value $5.99

    Solar-Power Fluttering Butterfly or Hummingbird

  • Green Thumb Pulsating Spike Sprinkler $7.99

    Green Thumb Pulsating Spike Sprinkler

  •  $24.99

    Green Thumb 2-Gal. Sprayer


  • 12-oz. Paint & Primer Spray Paint at True Value $3.49

    12-oz. Paint & Primer Spray Paint

  • Castrol GTX Motor Oil - Quart Size at True Value $3.99

    Castrol GTX Motor Oil - Quart Size

Our Services

We do Thermo Pane Repairs
Storms and Screens Repaired on Premises

Storms and screen windows and doors repaired
Storms and screens made to order

We participate in the Blue-Rhino propane exchange program
Lawn mower tune-ups done on premise
Keys cut while you wait


  • Mon - Sat: 8 am - 6 pm
  • Sun: 9 am - 5 pm